A TALE OF TWO CITIES

Dicken’s novel, set in London and Paris before and during the French Revolution is set to music by composer David Pomeranz and lyricist Steven David Horwich. Commissioned by director Paul Nicholas, it tells of the love and anguish of French peasants, brutal revolutionaries and ousted aristocrats. The musical has been in development over several years and was last seen in London during 2008, Upstairs at the Gatehouse. Nicholas states “The journey isn’t over” so there are clearly future aspirations, but for now Charing Cross Theatre plays host in the bicentennial year of Dicken’s birth. The book is a joint work by Horwich and David Soames, with musical arrangement by John Cameron.
The cast of seventeen must be the largest seen in this theatre for quite some time and it’s good to see the venue being put to such good use, having had such varied fortune over too long a period. A pair of pianos provide accompaniment to the pleasant score in a well-worked and complimentary fashion. Hipflask-grasping Sydney Carton is one of the two lead male characters and is well played by Michael Howe, filling the shoes once worn by Nicholas himself in an earlier Birmingham airing at the end of the nineties. Charles Darnay is a former nobleman who stands trial for treason to the Crown, played admirably by Jonathan Ansell, whose lyrically-rich duet ‘Fleeting Years’ with his teacher Gabelle (Tom Murphy) is particularly pleasing. Mark Slowey plays the devious Barsad with East-End flair. Craig Berry and Jemma Alexander shine as revolutionaries Monsieur and Madame Defarge; his ‘I See’ towards the end of the first act being a highlight. It is Alexander however who performs what is probably the best song ‘Why She Lived’ a number she deservedly conveys with great appetite and gusto.
David Alder is the veteran of the cast and at times I found his Jarvis Lorry, the banker, tiresome. However a delightfully arranged scene with the child Katherine (role shared by Tara Hayes, Eliza Light and Bells Wordsworth) on his knee and singing ‘Fleeting Years’ provided a tender touch. Snooty spinster Miss Pross is both frightful and amusing, Pippa Winslow plays the part with just the right balance of comedy and nose-in-the-air aloofness. Charged with caring for Katherine, she certainly proves to be no Mary Poppins. Her duet with Alder ‘I Remain Unwed’ providing an alluring diversion from the tribulations of the main plot, although both could do with relaxing a little more during its delivery.
Inevitably, there will be comparisons made with other musicals, notably Les Miserables which has musical and staging similarities, being set in the same period. A gun scene in act two has some likeness to the shooting in Love Never Dies. Miss Pross would certainly make a convincing sister to Madame Giry! However, set that aside and this production is entertaining and offers good value. Without exception, the lyrics are all fully discernable which makes a refreshing change. Suzi Lombardelli’s fine costumes add to the overall feeling of quality. So, does it follow that if you like Les Mis then you should like this too? I’m not sure, but I do and it works for me.
- - - - - - - - - -
REVIEWED: 18/04/12
By Gareth Richardson @BargainTheatre
5th April - 12th May 2012
Charing Cross Theatre, London, WC2.



